Tommy's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Paula Quinones 3 months ago

This place use to be the best, Is not the same lately, I just got 3 lasagnas with 0 cheese in them, 1 month ago I waited 2 hours for pizza, then they realized they never put my order in, after who ever picked up the phone was extremely rude as if it was my mistake, and kept asking me the same of the person I placed the order in, like if it was a business call. I don't think is even own by the same people, cooks are definitely not the same 100%.

Jessica Hale 5 months ago

In from out of town, looking for fast good food (which is very diffrent than "good fastfood"). Himself is picky, so I let him choose. My faith in him is rarely wrong, and he showed me why again, tonight. I had calamari. Himself had chicken parmesan. Mine came on a bed of lettuce (it's technically a starter, after all), and was delicious, and perfectly cooked (not rubbery at all!) His was a large portion of beautiful, toasted-cheese covered heaven, with a mound of s'ghetti that he said tasted much better than it looked. Cold drinks are cans or bottles. There was a sign that indicated coffee might be available. If our personal opinion is insufficient, I would point out that there was a table of, let's call them "distinguished fellows", who the employees seemed familiar with... I suspect they are regulars - as I would also be, if I were local.

Jorge Martínez Gualdrón - Photographer 7 months ago

If you’re looking for pizza made with true Italian character, Tommy’s Pizzeria is the place to go. You can taste the authenticity in every slice — from the perfectly crafted dough to the fresh, high-quality ingredients. It’s clear that a real Italian touch goes into every preparation, guaranteeing both flavor and freshness. The service is welcoming and efficient. You’re greeted with friendliness, and the wait time is impressively short, which makes the experience even better. On top of that, the prices are very reasonable for the level of quality you receive. In the Elizabeth area, this is hands down the best pizza I’ve tried. I highly recommend the restaurant and its convenient location. Great food, great service, excellent prices — definitely a spot worth coming back to. 🍕🇮🇹

David Pisanelli a year ago

Hi I order two pies one extra cheese one half cheese half pepperoni the first pie doesn’t have extra cheese I’ve worked in pizza over 10 years as an Italian American I’m insulted when I called the restaurant the person on the phone said the pizza has extra cheese and the reason why it isn’t noticeable is because we ( the customer) too to long to pick up the order basically the cheese evaporated which makes no sense in the photo clearly showing there’s no extra cheese

Brent Augustus a year ago

This was a slam dunk! Great New York style Pizza in a great shop. The pizza was delicious, great flavorful crust and sauce, good balance of toppings. Garlic knots were SO GOOD! I'll be back for sure